Photos description: "Case No. 7906174 - The Amish Thief". Annie Archer is not your typical thief, and as it turns out, she doesn’t even realize she’s stealing anything from the store. Loss prevention officer Rusty Nails explains that the barter system doesn’t work in his store, and things need to be paid for with cash. As a middle ground, there is something Annie can do to barter her way out of this sticky situation.